Dark Legacy MUD Forum

Celeborn - 9.6 (for hardwork)
Zeraphin - 8.9
Isabelle - 9.8
Chloe - 9.9
Garion - 8.4
Roje - 8.7
Phuti - 4.5 (former "caretaker")
Frellios - 4.5 (former caretaker)
Harax - 8.8
Radyn - 2.1 (former "caretaker")
Kelryne - 9.4 (too new)

How would you guys rate them?

btw, this is solely based on observations. Things that they do in the background are not taken in consideration.

Just counting what people have actually see them doing?

Celeborn - 10
Isabelle - 9.4
Roje - 7.5
Chloe - 8.1
Garion - 5
Rest - 0

My actual opinions...Bit different

ALL - 10

On a scale of 1 - 10, 10 being the best.

Cele: 11
Roje: 10.5

And those are the only ones that I feel like ranking.

lingolas wrote:Celeborn - 9.6 (for hardwork)
Zeraphin - 8.9
Isabelle - 9.8
Chloe - 9.9
Garion - 8.4
Roje - 8.7
Phuti - 4.5 (former "caretaker")
Frellios - 4.5 (former caretaker)
Harax - 8.8
Radyn - 2.1 (former "caretaker")
Kelryne - 9.4 (too new)

How would you guys rate them?

btw, this is solely based on observations. Things that they do in the background are not taken in consideration.

How did you get Zeraphin to 8.9... before the forums the _ONLY_ things he did were in the background... and the forums are quite recent .... Harax is barely around so I dontt think he deserves an 8.8 No offense to chloe but I do not believe she should get more then isabelle... she (Isa) does HEAPS of work.... I won't comment on Radyn because I'm biased

Oh yeah... garion is never around and now goes by the name rhoran... and i've never actually seen (with my own eyes) him do anything productive

Harhar. Quite correct. I mostly work in the background, and rarely, even during my most active phases, posted or made public what I was working on. I also try to avoid having to deal with players cackle. I spend about 95% of my online time invisible, and always have over the past 4-5 years.

well, this is a collective observation over a period of 3 years. my entire DL experience. NOtice names like frellios? Harax is no longer active, but he's still a very likable titan. zeraphin may or may not be active, but i can't recall anyone having any beef with him and he works hard as far as i know so he gets high ratings at well. My rating isn't based entirely on hardwork, but also based on observed relationship with other mortals.

*rofl*

Ratings based on Caretaker ass-kissing:

Lingolas - 11
Kiasyn - 11
Quintos - 8 (no explanation on that one)
Weemster - 4 (because, well wait, let me change that to a 0 because his nose is never brown)

What a way to show them how you feel, wouldn't be suprised if the negative feelings were mutual.

Okay. First off Kariyana I agree.. partially...

BUUUUUUUUUT

Kiasyn kisses more arse. MUCH more.

now. Should I post my ratings? ah sure. THe imms that I don't like know it.

Cele:10. Hes the creator what can I say?
Isa: 7-8 Shes good, around.. sometimes not too friendly though
Chloe:6-7 Would be an 8.. but she started aving all my chars names.
Roje: Who the hell.... Roje? Whodat?
Radyn:-23942832983 Note the negative. I would write what I think of her... but I won't, cause my post will be removed.
Harax:10 My favourite imm.
Garion: 4-5ish... he never really.. did anything that I saw...
Zeraphin: 5-6.. He removed my note. and I've never seen him do much.. and I think he was slow to get the guild fledging crap goin..

Uh... I think that's it... And I'm not sucking up, this is what I think. I don't care if the imms like me or not.. Some don't, some do.

This is such a silly post. I am not going to delete it or anything evil like that. But guys....come on :-p

I will say this: Cele, Zera, and Isy should all get high praise all the time for the level of work that gets put into the game by these guys over the past years. And yeah, a lot of it is behind the scenes. But if it the behind the scenes stuff did not get done, the game would come to a hault. I think we should be appreciative of all the hard work that they have done.

And my rating should definately be ∏ or ℮ .

Well Chloe, that's what I meant. Lingolas asked for ratings according to what is seen of them doing. I know that certain imms are doing a hell of a lot behind the scenes and deserve higher ratings.

Yay, Tuler rated me right. I get annoyed when people think highly of me, I was gone from the game on hiatus from January 2004 to beginning of July 2004, so it would be hard for you to have seen me do much!

I think people often forget that I am Jessie and Ayame as well though.

I rate myself a 1. I don't play this really anymore so I don't really sign on anymore. And Zera...gimme admin on your CS servers!!!

Thanks for the ratings. They are fun to read.

I do wish that I could come back more, but so much has already changed, including my life. I seem to be busy 24/7. Who knows, maybe some day I will be able to come back and be a productive member of the Caretaker staff.

Well Zera... You do all your stuff behind the scenes, and if I saw that, you might get higher.. and Chloe is a good imm... cept she av'd all my chars names.. lol But she's good, not around much (for good reason) but yeah..

Harax owns though.

Here you have it folks from Binkly himself:

Isabelle - 2 on Conduct with other players (favors people and is a bitch to the unfavored) As far as the mud work goes for this immortal I'd rate 8, I imagine she is such a bitch to the unfavored partly because of her "outside the scene" work.

Celeborn - Of course getting a 10 for both player conduct and his work. Not only is he the game creator, but he has always treated me and the other players of the mud very fairly. Good guy all around.

Zeraphin - 6 for conduct, is quite fair but can be edgy from time to time, 8 for the work.. however the time off that he needed to take may have affected this rating, his former work as Ayame was done very well and much time spent on the mud, doing this work, as well.

Radyn - I won't even step into this one...

Roje - 9 for player conduct, not biased what-so-ever... always fair, BUT sometimes quick to pull the trigger so to speak... work i'll give her an 8, she has been trying to get some areas built into the mud for the past while now.

Garion - 10 for conduct... somewhat of the Caretaker Jester.. 0 for work, Jabba the Hut of TSQ.

Harax - 8 for conduct.. from the time he was on a LONG time ago as much as he was, he was always fair and kind to the people. 7 for past work, he devoted alot of his time in the past, deserves the 7, things come up in life. don't worry we understand Harax

Chloe - ah yes, the ever-so controversial caretaker... another one who is quick to jump the gun, however if you catch her before she jumps the gun she will be fair and leniant enough to listen to your part of the story, I have alot of respect for this immortal, does very well to stop the domestic disputes on DL to the best of her abilities. Sometimes people don't like how she will judge the situation, but put yourself in her shoes for a moment people. so 8 for conduct. 6 for work, again i'm not sure what she does exactly, from what i gather its more or less the jailing and solving fights between players, which she does well.

Any other immortals I may have left out, I haven't had enough time playing anymore to experience how they see fit to run things, so I will just leave them out of my ratings. Thanks for your time, Binkly

all of the caretakers get rated 3 because it takes 3 minutes to make ramen and this thread is a bunch of kiss asses and im not a kiss ass so

/me waits for slay

takes 2 minutes in New Zealand

kiasyn wrote:takes 2 minutes in New Zealand

I beg to differ. Meh is a master ramen maker, nobody could possibly make it faster than him.

shrug... maybe its a hemisphere thing

i only got a 2 on being a bitch to retards! I deserve a -10!

*hugs Isabelle*

wub oo!

*walks away whistling, weighting the purse of gold*

Celeborn: 10 - he made the game....he has to get a 10
Zeraphin: 7 - would be higher but he's inactive
Chloe: 6 - Banning me does not count as a productive activity
Radyn: 0 - She doesn't exist anymore
Roje: 5 - No comment, I value my current "not banned" status
Isabelle: -10 - DIE ISA
Kelryne: 10 - ^_^
Phuti: ? - Didn't actually do anything, that I'm aware of
Garion: 9 - He sexually harasses other imms
Harax: ? - Never had much to do with him


@Zeraphin: Wasn't Ayame you and Chloe, and who was Jessie? Another Immortal char?

I was both Ayame and Jessie, merely changed names twice over the past five years, shifting themes and character ideas from a roleplay point of view that never quite materialized.. Chloe has only been Chloe. I'm also not inactive I'm invis