Hello Chloe, hope your family is fine. I looked at the seats you listed, and to be honest the ads don’t give sufficient detail. Off-hand, I would choose the Cosco that you have as your second choice. But I still would like to see it in a store first. As a rule of thumb for babies and small children, a seat that can be secured in a backward fashion is safer. Of course it has been a long time since I needed a car seat for Catra, I am sure they have made improvements since then. Why don’t you try some of the consumer research groups and see how these seats faired with them. Sorry I am not more help. Take care and best wishes to you and yours.
